Crystal could have redeem the four sisters

[Clow]

It was so nice of them to wear 1980s/90s era couture despite being from so far in the future.

That style kinda made a comeback.

 

[imaginationgirl]

It's not hard to add some to make them redeemable, such as misguided by Wiseman and recruited into the BMC, just like Another Story's opposite senshi.

I do not think that would work .That would for one would be a big change from the manga .
The second part none of the black moon characters were misguided . They joined Wisemen willingly ,to destroy eath .Then to re write history .

 

[Slowpokeking]

I do not think that would work .That would for one would be a big change from the manga .
The second part none of the black moon characters were misguided . They joined Wisemen willingly ,to destroy eath .Then to re write history .

They were misguided in the manga as well, as Wiseman was using them and hide his purpose.

Also their goal was not to destroy earth, Demande went too rushed(Saphir was against it) by dropping the big black crystal and turned earth into a place of death, which is not even his intention, then they switched target to present time to rewrite history.

They mostly wanted to conquer earth and direct it with their idea, since against eternal life was not entirely a nonsense, it could be possible that some of its members were not beyond redemption, even Demande did regret in the end.

 

[Clow]

Demande didn’t show any remorse after discovering the truth about Wiseman; he grabbed the two silver crystals and nobody knows what he intended to do—probably take his own life and drag the entire universe with him.

 

[imaginationgirl]

They were misguided in the manga as well, as Wiseman was using them and hide his purpose.

Also their goal was not to destroy earth, Demande went too rushed(Saphir was against it) by dropping the big black crystal and turned earth into a place of death, which is not even Demande's intention, then they switched target to present time to rewrite history.

They mostly wanted to conquer earth and direct it with their idea mostly, since against eternal life was not entirely a nonsense, it could be possible that some of its members were not beyond redemption, even Demande did regret in the end.

I was paraphrasing ,and yes they were used . But still they were trying to destroy the current future . They still killed mostly everyone,and try to rewrite future .These are not misguided naive children . These were killers who were in a death cult.Who hated the current future ,and rejected it .

 

[Slowpokeking]

Demande didn’t show any remorse after discovering the truth about Wiseman; he grabbed the two silver crystals and nobody knows what he intended to do—probably take his own life and everyone else’s.

He did feel bad about his brother and did think that Sailor Moon was indeed bright when she tried to go against the crystal, just his brother's death and he was fooled all along had drove him into nuts so he wanted to destroy everything.

But if we are talking about Crystal, he did pick his sense back in the end and blocked the attack with his life.

 

[Clow]

Koan is a ruthless killer in the manga.

 

[Slowpokeking]

I was paraphrasing ,and yes they were used . But still they were trying to destroy the current future . They still killed mostly everyone,and try to rewrite future .These are not misguided naive children . These were killers who were in a death cult.Who hated the current future ,and rejected it .

But it was not really their intention, Saphir was even against his brother's doing. It would not be a surprise if someone among the group was against massive killing but at the same time dislike eternal life as well.

Also from both Endymion and Demande's flashback, the sisters were not among the BMC members who left Earth, it's highly possible that the sisters were new recruits later.

 

[Slowpokeking]

Koan is a ruthless killer in the manga.

It's just a minor plot and can be easily changed, like Demande didn't kill that child in Crystal as well.

We are not talking about how does it happen in the manga, but could it be changed with current length and not change the main plot.

 

[imaginationgirl]

But it was not really their intention, Saphir was even against his brother's doing. It would not be a surprise if someone among the group was against massive killing but at the same time dislike eternal life as well.

Also from both Endymion and Demande's flashback, the sisters were not among the BMC members who left Earth, it's highly possible that the sisters were new recruits later.

I think you are stretching it. This was there intention . Why you don't see The four sisters . That doesn't mean they didn't joined .And lets say they did after that .They join evil cult after they kill billions ? That doesn't make them look good .

 

[Slowpokeking]

I think you are stretching it. This was there intention . Why you don't see The four sisters . That doesn't mean they didn't joined .And lets say they did after that .They join evil cult after they kill billions ? That doesn't make them look good .

It wasn't, their goal was to conquer earth and destroy the eternal life style, not killing everyone and left nothing to run. Otherwise they would have no need to travel back in time, just focus on the future.

No, I'm saying that they probably joined it between the formation of BMC and the black crystal dropped to the future.

It's possible that they didn't have a word to say about the decision. Even Saphir could not stop his brother from doing it.

Still all of this could be easily made into reasonable characterization of the sisters without a overhaul of the main plot.

 

[SILVER]

Hell no.

It makes no sense for them to be redeemed in Crystal when the story is different in structure, characterization and themes. Demand being given a slight redemption upon death still had the same outcome, and it fit. I personally enjoyed seeing the sisters as powerful enemies instead.

 

[julayla]

I always thought that none of them could be redeemed because, at least in my theory, the sisters were just droids created by them (same with all the other Black Moon clan if we're to go with only Wiseman back then being the one banished due to being a war criminal, I mean how the heck was there only one person in the time he was banished and then more people in Black Moon anyway?). But that's just my own headcanon for the Manga/Crystal, something not to be taken seriously.

 

[morri]

The shinttenou were mamorus guadian in the manga too, there was no reason to redeem one shot character like the sisters, as in the Manga they really were one shot characters really.