Pick the next Character Designer for the Stars arc/Final Season

  • This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn more.

sapphire91

Aurorae Lunares
Jul 6, 2018
1,809
1,539
1,665
29
#26
I wonder if Keiko Iwata could design properly, or she will face the trouble like Sakou Yukie again. Because even in Act 21 and 25, her drawings are not perfect and need to fix a lot in the BD release.
Act 25: Showdown -DEATH PHANTOM- | Crystal Comparisons
Her drawings didn't really needed fixes. They enhanced some, but her work on this episode is as good as always. She did very few scenes. If the other animators mess up it would turn out bad though. This is why they decided to simplify stuff. Especially in season 1 Akiras work got redrawn a lot and constantly off model, but he still got the job tue do the simplicity.
 

Crystal Moon

Lumen Cinereum
Jul 11, 2013
1,760
299
165
#27
Her drawings didn't really needed fixes. They enhanced some, but her work on this episode is as good as always. She did very few scenes. If the other animators mess up it would turn out bad though. This is why they decided to simplify stuff. Especially in season 1 Akiras work got redrawn a lot and constantly off model, but he still got the job tue do the simplicity.
I think Akira is a man full of pride. He never allowed anyone fix his drawings. In Act 10 and 14, there were 5 people in the staff. And the characters are almost on model, and the head shape is mostly round. And then he got rid of that person, and episode 18, 22 and 26 got worse. It looks to me that he wanted to opposed to Sakou Yukie till the last moment, and nobody could do anything about him.
 
Likes: SILVER
Jan 17, 2007
2,014
781
665
#28
I actually am not sure if Keiko Iwata's designs would have the same issues as Sako. She is definitely superior in understanding proportion (look at how balanced Princess Serenity's headshape is!) and anatomy (and her eyes are super expressive). She's also pretty flexible as an artist and I think she'd approach the designs knowing that not everyone will be able to imitate her level of detail. Animation direction and character designs are very separate jobs and the character designer's job is to make sure the designs can be ANIMATED first and not just imitate the manga's style.

Like even her PIXIV art on the first page is actually simpler than S1's designs (aside from the details in the hair and clothing). Like the eye shape is actually somewhat reminiscent of Precure, but like Naoko-ified.
 

Seen2

Lumen Cinereum
Nov 16, 2016
259
299
165
#29
I think Akira is a man full of pride. He never allowed anyone fix his drawings. In Act 10 and 14, there were 5 people in the staff. And the characters are almost on model, and the head shape is mostly round. And then he got rid of that person, and episode 18, 22 and 26 got worse. It looks to me that he wanted to opposed to Sakou Yukie till the last moment, and nobody could do anything about him.
Or, you know, he just drew close enough to being on-model that nobody bothered to correct his stuff that much. I'm pretty sure animators don't get much of a say in these things.

God, I hate this fandom's irresponsible rumor-mongering.
A few weeks ago there was an art collector on ANN saying Ikuko Itoh hated Sailor Moon because she didn't seem to want to talk about it or seemed interested in her work on it when autographing her art from it (when they were at a panel dedicated to Princess Tutu.)
What's sad is that there's slightly more ground to that speculation than this because someone actually visited her at a con.

It's fine if you don't like season 3's art. It's not fine to start dragging a real life person's name through the mud because of it.
 

sapphire91

Aurorae Lunares
Jul 6, 2018
1,809
1,539
1,665
29
#30
I think Akira is a man full of pride. He never allowed anyone fix his drawings. In Act 10 and 14, there were 5 people in the staff. And the characters are almost on model, and the head shape is mostly round. And then he got rid of that person, and episode 18, 22 and 26 got worse. It looks to me that he wanted to opposed to Sakou Yukie till the last moment, and nobody could do anything about him.
I doubt he opposed. He has a signature style and is not versatile. The same Ikuko Itou is very good designer and animator, but cannot escape her style once she developped it. And his episoded while simpler in style had a lot less issues and most likely were faster and smoother to produce. I am ok with Tadano so far, and if they keep her for Stars I doubt I will have any problem with her. She do round and simple enough, but still quite pretty.
 
Likes: Crystal Moon

SailorSpySedna

Lumen Cinereum
May 18, 2016
480
301
165
#31

Crystal Moon

Lumen Cinereum
Jul 11, 2013
1,760
299
165
#32
Or, you know, he just drew close enough to being on-model that nobody bothered to correct his stuff that much. I'm pretty sure animators don't get much of a say in these things.

God, I hate this fandom's irresponsible rumor-mongering.
A few weeks ago there was an art collector on ANN saying Ikuko Itoh hated Sailor Moon because she didn't seem to want to talk about it or seemed interested in her work on it when autographing her art from it (when they were at a panel dedicated to Princess Tutu.)
What's sad is that there's slightly more ground to that speculation than this because someone actually visited her at a con.

It's fine if you don't like season 3's art. It's not fine to start dragging a real life person's name through the mud because of it.
Okay. I'll take my words back.
 

NJ_

Aurorae Lunares
Oct 31, 2009
7,503
1,106
1,665
34
Wallington, NJ
#33
God, I hate this fandom's irresponsible rumor-mongering.
A few weeks ago there was an art collector on ANN saying Ikuko Itoh hated Sailor Moon because she didn't seem to want to talk about it or seemed interested in her work on it when autographing her art from it (when they were at a panel dedicated to Princess Tutu.)
What's sad is that there's slightly more ground to that speculation than this because someone actually visited her at a con.
Ah Cutiebunny.....so it WAS centered around Tutu? She didn't mention that in her reply to me but I had a feeling it was something like that since the same used to happen for Ikuhara events like the Q&A Right Stuf did 9 years ago where all questions asked had to be Utena-related since they just license-rescued the series at the time.