Season 4 movies update: Sailor Moon Eternal - Delayed to 2021 (Part 1 on January 8th & Part 2 on February 11th)

  • This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn more.

JunoDX

Solaris Luna
Nov 8, 2018
2,235
3,856
1,665
39
This is so irritating. Here we have something that is creative and dynamic. It's like what on Earth is going on with the creative team. This would have been nice if animated for a movie. I like how involved this transformation looks. Not to sound negative about the film but this version makes the one I saw for Usagi's birthday look real "wooden".
well, i guess this was not made by toei. plus - the models can‘t be off model.
 
Dec 7, 2009
992
390
165
34
All the extra flips and whirls were kinda weird. I kinda feel like it's supposed to be a transformation, not a ballet haha. Prefer what we got over this.
 
Jul 31, 2012
5,456
4,653
1,665
Outer Space
To me that's what separates Sailor Moon transformations from other shows. It had an elegance to it that was like a graceful ballet dancer. Most of the transformations now have that Pretty Cure fast, "Boom, Boom, Pop" type of transformation stuff even though the transformations take forever.

Like Moon Crystal Power Make Up was elegant. From the ribbons flowing to how everything seemed ethereal. Now most stuff seems like a pop music video. I was listening to a song from the S movie called Shou and Sentou and that's the kind of music I miss from the series.
 
Last edited:
Likes: Starlight
Dec 7, 2009
992
390
165
34
Yes but Moon Crystal Power didn't have excessive twirling and whirling, each movement coincided with the transformation. She stretches her arms gracefully, her gloves appear. We see her perfect on pointe toes, her boots appear etc.

In my opinion 90s Moon Prism and Moon Crystal transformations should be what any transformation sequence should strive to be. They were absolutely perfect.
 

sapphire91

Stella Nova
Jul 6, 2018
6,668
9,485
1,665
I watched the „new“ transformation again and again. it looks unfinished bit they can fix it here and there, add some frames and it will look decent.
My only biggest problem with it is when they are back to back in the original they move their hands a bit to the side and it looks elegent. In the new one they keep them close to the torso and they look like corpses... It is literatry one movement that could make a difference. I am mostly mad because they choose to showcase a transformation over 30 seconds of something else. Yes they wanted Chibi Usa and Usagi, and they might have shown original footage from the film - like them slapping bodies - it fits the birthday theme and it would have been original footage. We have seen like 10 frames of original footage that is not remake... If they didn't make this transformation a focus and promo material it could have passed in the actual film. But they put so much emphasis on the recreated stuff from the 90s and it pales in comparison... There are many people, like me that focus on other stuff rather than the stock footage and the backlash would have been a lot less. We want to see their actual work, rather than 90s v. 2.0.
 
Last edited:

JunoDX

Solaris Luna
Nov 8, 2018
2,235
3,856
1,665
39
My only biggest problem with it is when they are back to back in the original they move their hands a bit to the side and it looks elegent. In the new one they keep them close to the torso and they look like corpses... It is literatry one movement that could make a difference. I am mostly mad because they choose to showcase a transformation over 30 seconds of something else. Yes they wanted Chibi Usa and Usagi, and they might have shown original footage from the film - like them slapping bodies - it fits the birthday theme and it would have been original footage. We have seen like 10 frames of original footage that is not remake... If they didn't make this transformation a focus and promo material it could have passed in the actual film. But they put so much emphasis on the recreated stuff from the 90s and it pales in comparison... There are many people, like me that focus on other stuff rather than the stock footage and the backlash would have been a lot less. We want to see their actual work, rather than 90s v. 2.0.
I don‘t know if the shitstorm on youtube affects the production, i don‘t know if it‘s calculated or if toei believes that what they showed is good quality.

I hope they will add a background in the beginning when we see the two brooches, and change the cheap particles with some handdrawn effects
 

Seira Hazuki

Solaris Luna
Jan 17, 2007
2,899
4,271
1,665
While I don't think the animation will be even touched, I do hope at the very least they improved the sound effects and some of the particle effects (since that's done through post production).

Like the transformation feels so weird because it's so quiet... The ribbons come out and it's like ~silence~.

And yeah the particles look cheap compared to what we saw in Moon Cosmic Power last season which was beautifully done by Shida. I'm not expecting anything at that level at this point, but surely instead of having hearts come out for both Usagi and Chibiusa, Usagi should get little moons?
 

JunoDX

Solaris Luna
Nov 8, 2018
2,235
3,856
1,665
39
While I don't think the animation will be even touched, I do hope at the very least they improved the sound effects and some of the particle effects (since that's done through post production).

Like the transformation feels so weird because it's so quiet... The ribbons come out and it's like ~silence~.

And yeah the particles look cheap compared to what we saw in Moon Cosmic Power last season which was beautifully done by Shida. I'm not expecting anything at that level at this point, but surely instead of having hearts come out for both Usagi and Chibiusa, Usagi should get little moons?

I also miss the "grinding sparks", i always thought they make it look like they are getting an iron armor.

 

SailorSugababe

Aurorae Lunares
Sep 8, 2011
1,472
511
665
^ The fact that Pegasus is still the same size as in the teaser trailer should answer everyone’s question whether they’ll “improve” the animation for the transformation.

(hint: they won’t.)
I think smaller pegasus was fully intentional.

Im still unsure what to think. The speech part looks fluid. The transformation doesnt. The attacks we saw look pretty fluid aswell. Im not gonna put my faith into Toei too much but i think there is a small chance they will correct the transformation.

At least so far we didnt saw ugly/derpy faces. Thats a small plus
 
Likes: MsImagination

sapphire91

Stella Nova
Jul 6, 2018
6,668
9,485
1,665
I think smaller pegasus was fully intentional.

Im still unsure what to think. The speech part looks fluid. The transformation doesnt. The attacks we saw look pretty fluid aswell. Im not gonna put my faith into Toei too much but i think there is a small chance they will correct the transformation.

At least so far we didnt saw ugly/derpy faces. Thats a small plus
we haven't seen much original footage though. Most of it is retraced, the transformation, the speech, the attacks minus Mercury, the group shot of the girls. It is easy to stay on model when you are copying. And the new original frame with Pegasus gives me the usual Crystal quality. I am not bothered by his size, but the girls look quite of model and Diana is.... Well, why they are advertizing with such shody frames? Then the other original shot with Usagi huging Mamoru. It us too bright, but I can see her face is off model a bit. But the hair animation looks fine in it.
 
Last edited: