The '90s Films vs Their Respective Seasons

[MementoNepenthe]

Just curious: Which do you guys prefer?

 

[Star Angel Haruki]

I'm not going to go into the extrwme specifics and just touch on entertainment appeal.

R Movie. Perfect representation of the entire season and I like the appeal it had with nice animation.

S series. I personally find the S movie boring but it has great music.


SuperS Movie. Very entertaining film. Probably more entertaining than R movie but not as emotionally moving towards the climax.

 

[Frenchfries&AChocolateMalt]

Since S and SuperS were so damn formulaic I prefer the movies to the series

 

[Clow]

I liked the 90’s anime when I was a kid.

Today I only follow the manga and Crystal, so I only like the S movie.

 

[Starlight]

Both the R season and movie are great. I can't possibly choose. It's a tie for me. However, I definitely prefer the S and SuperS seasons over their respective films.

 

[Seira Hazuki]

R movie > R the series: While I love a lot about R, the movie just feels so perfect and succinct and doesn't have some terrible plotlines like the breakup plot.

S the series >>>>>>>>>>>>> S movie: No offense, but the Princess Kaguya's Lover story is kinda meh in both the manga and the '90s anime.

SuperS Movie >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> SuperS the series: This one is a no-brainer for me. Perle has more chemistry with Chibiusa in the 5 minutes they interacted than the entire 30 something episodes of Pegasus and Chibiusa (and he's not a horse!). The senshi seem way more competent in the movie and as much as people make a big deal about SuperS' animation, the movie completley blows it out of the water. The Outers appear. Chibi Moon has an actual attack. Did I mention no Horse x Little Girl romance?

 

[MementoNepenthe]

Seems like the general consensus so far is that the R film, S season, and SuperS film are the superior versions.