Black_Chaos said:
The series is far from mediocre, the manga tells a great story that we now get to see animated, and brought along new music and merchandise among other things.
I agree that the manga tells a great story, but I disagree that we now get to see it animated when Crystal has completely butchered it, at least the first two arcs, by cutting scenes/characters, removing humor and characterization, making heinously stupid changes, and being little more than "A Really Bad Redraw of the Manga: A PowerPoint Presentation" at times.
As for new merchandise, that started with the 20th Anniversary celebration (which is still going on...four years later
) In fact, most of the new merchandise has used 90s anime artwork in its promotion/design. There hasn't been all that much in terms of Crystal-specific merchandise, and most of that has either been food or bizarre (a robotic vacuum cleaner, tampons, etc).
I will agree with you on the new music, though; that has been fantastic.
Black_Chaos said:
There are some bad frames , and questionable proportions but when watching it in real time did you really notice them and was that alone really enough to take you out of the experience? When you watch a show do you seriously watch it one frame at a time or hunt for every single error possible?
To answer your first question: YES. Because there weren't "some" bad frames, there were HUNDREDS of them. And they weren't "blink and you'll miss it" either; they stayed on-screen for long periods of time. I didn't have to hunt for errors; they were there for all to see, plain as Mars's broken anatomy.
Black_Chaos said:
My 90's elitist comments stem from the fact that time and time again I read how some "fans" whine that Crystal isn't "like the 90's anime, doesn't have a bunch of filler, doesn't re-use the old music , etc.)
I think 90's fans are disappointed that Crystal hasn't played, for instance, Moonlight Densetsu, but because they think that would be an appropriate throwback/homage. However, I haven't seen more than a couple of fans seriously hate on Crystal for that. Similarly, some fans wished Crystal used the 90's character designs, not because they were against new designs, but because they didn't like what Crystal came up with and, liking the original designs, would naturally have preferred their reuse. (Not unlike certain Crystal fans wishing the seasons I and II designs were still being used instead of the season III designs, but apparently only Crystal fans are allowed to be unhappy with changes.) As for filler, that has nothing to do with the 90's anime; it's a valid criticism of Crystal that it needed more episodes to flesh out the plot and characters and fix its pacing issues. Even if the 90's anime didn't exist, people would still be saying Crystal needs more "filler" episodes.
Black_Chaos said:
Season 3 came out well even though I liked the original art style better, and really Black Moon was pretty good, most of the issues seem to center on Dark Kingdom. They obviously have improved things as the series continues, plus there's seemingly going to be a decent gap between Infinity and Dream so Dream should look fine. Not supporting Crystal isn't going to help the show improve or make Toei want to give us more content.
There was a big gap between Black Moon and Infinity yet the animation was still mediocre, they recycled footage like never before, and didn't even attempt to improve things for the BD, so barring some major staff changes, I'm not gonna hold my breath for Dream looking any better. As for not supporting Crystal, where did I say that? I bought the Mook, I bought the Soundtrack, and I've bought a bunch of 20th Anniversary merchandise. Toei/Kodansha/PNP have gotten a TON of my money over the years, so I'm well and truly entitled to complain.