also if you say that Sailor Moon Another Story uses manga elements so too do the CD Dramas
No they don’t because the Drama CDs were made by Toei and Another Story by a completely different company. Toei’s canon for Sailor Moon in the 90’s was the 90’s anime and that was it. Also all of the Dramas I’ve seen so far have been completely 90’s anime based such as KunZoi being a couple (not even any mention of Senshi/Shittenou being a thing like Another Story
does have) Boy-Crazy Rei who used to date Mamoru, the Ayakashi Sisters being redeemed and Petz being involved with Saphir + Saphir’s feelings for Demande. These are all purely 90’s anime exclusive elements, so no the Drama CDs do not in fact follow manga canon at all.
Also Demand loves Saphir as a brother and a subordinate not as a lover so he dosen't love him for who he is.
Do you not understand what I’ve been saying? I don’t
care if Demande doesn’t love Saphir romantically, even if he only loves him as a brother I’m satisfied with the fact that that platonic love comes from who Saphir is as a
person rather than JUST because he’s his brother. His brotherly feelings of love for Saphir aren’t fake like UsaMamo’s lover feelings are in the 90’s anime.
Contrary to popular belief I don’t in fact need all my ships to end up together and return the other’s feelings equally in canon, it’s good enough for me that there’s chemistry between them, the relationship is interesting, and perhaps most importantly,
it isn’t a forced relationship and both care for the other out of their own free will!
Like I said I would much rather have one person in my ships be a cuck then for them to choose only each other but that choice is being grounded purely in destiny and a forced obligation.
I would honestly be more willing to ship UsaMamo if I did see Mamoru growing to genuinely care about Usagi as his best friend but never being in love with her and if they didn’t have that past and future life tying them together. I do not need my ships to get together officially or even for their romantic feelings for the other to be reciprocated/equal so long as whatever feelings of care that
are there are genuine.
Also Saori and Kobayashi never thought that Usagi and Mamoru's relationship was "pedophilic" they just thought that Usagi wasn't mature enough for Mamoru but no where did they find it pedophilic. If they did they would find Mamoru a horrible person and Saori wouldn't want to date him. In fact since she is going into law enforcement she would try and arrest them.
Saori didn’t try to arrest Mamoru because she
knows that Mamoru isn’t a pedo and that there’s no way he’d ever be attracted to someone as immature and childish as Usagi was being in that moment so of course the likely alternative in her mind was that he was just humoring Usagi and she and Chibi-Usa were girls he babysat or something.
Like the idea of Mamoru being genuinely attracted to a girl like Usagi was so preposterous Saori and Kobayashi didn’t even believe he was dating her, they thought it was just one whole big joke and he’s humoring the children he’s babysitting.
Even Kobayashi had to ask for Usagi’s age in that episode because he got the impression she wasn’t that much older than Chibi-Usa and he was
shocked when she said she was 15!
It definitely appeared as pedophilic to them, they just didn’t take it seriously and thought Mamoru was humoring these two little kids.
Just like with the cries of calling someone a racist, sexist, a homophobe etc calling people groomers and pedos when it dosen't apply just cheapens the word as you have all ready done so. At this point you use the term pedo so inaccurately you might as well come off as a which as you sound like a puritan.
I didn’t say Mamoru
is a pedo, I said his relationship with Usagi in the 90’s anime
looks pedophilic, there’s a difference.
Also the Miracle Romance is baked into the series and it's foundation so if you don't like it then you are a anti fan.
So does that mean the majority of the American SM fandom are “anti fans” now? You do realize it’s possible to be into a series for
some of it’s aspects and not
all of them right? You don’t need to blindly worship or even
like every little detail about a franchise in order to be considered “a true fan.”
Plus you keep using the manga as if it was done better when there is very little difference between Usagi and Mamoru or their relationship dynamic in either the anime or manga
It’s done better for the sole fact that Mamoru and Usagi are clearly already in love with each other and were about to ask the other out before getting their memories back.
Also Mamoru learned Usagi was Sailor Moon early on so there was never that disconnect between the two in his mind we can be sure he was attracted to Usagi for
all of her, not just
part of her whose other half he didn’t even know the identity of.
And he didn’t outright bully her like in the 90’s anime either, only lightly teased her but cut that sh*t out only a few chapters in.
Also they didn't make Haruka into a TERF because Drag Queens are not trans people
This is true however most TERFs seem to despise even men just cross-dressing, hence the whole “A woman is not a costume!” bullsh*t they like to repeat ad-nauseam. So yes, making Haruka prejudiced against Drag Queens in the Drama CDs is in fact making her TERFy. Maybe not an outright TERF but it’s TERFy behavior.
Also Mamoru could leave Usagi after he has Chibiusa. Hell he could easily knock up Usagi with Chibiusa, have her and then the two break up and become co parents. They could even rule Crystal Tokyo not as a couple but Co Regents.
Did you not read one of my previous replies where I said Sailor Moon isn’t the sort of franchise to ever do this? It’s for little kids (or at least the 90’s anime was), for the explicit purpose of selling toys, and in children’s media having a kid together = getting married, kids shows never acknowledge casual sex or even donor insemination, those are both considered to be adult topics.
So no, in the Sailor Moon world if Usagi and Mamoru are to have Chibi-Usa they need to get married to each other someday.
Honestly a better alternative would be to just have Chibi-Usa’s father be someone else, or have Usagi reproduce her like Queen Serenity did her in the Manga via the Galaxy Cauldron. It’s not like Chibs has much of Mamoru in her anyways, she’s pretty much just a clone of Usagi both in looks and personality,
especially in the 90’s anime.
Plus if he truly didn't love Usagi as you stated then Chibiusa would have never come into existence as he would have just moved on but he didn't.
Do you not remember how Crystal Tokyo came into existence in the anime? He couldn’t “just move on” because the entire Earth got encased in ice and his Endymion spirit + Usagi’s Serenity’s spirit had to reawaken to unfreeze the Earth and establish Crystal Tokyo. They have to get together for Crystal Tokyo to happen because the whole entire reason it comes into existence in the first place is because their past lives spirits took over their bodies and resumed the Silver Millenium dynasty.
That’s as “destined with no choice in the matter” as you can get!
Also you really don't see how the trauma of Mamoru being kidnapped and taken from her could hype up her jealousy in general.
What does Mamoru constantly getting kidnapped have to do with her worrying that he might prefer someone else over her? Which is what jealousy is all about, it’s not merely the fear of your love interest being taken away from you but they themselves
loving or
being attracted to someone else more - it’s based around one’s own sense of inferiority towards another person and insecurity in themselves, whereas someone kidnapping and brainwashing your loved one has nothing to do with you being worried about how you measure up to the kidnapper, but the kidnapper simply being a dick who you have to take down.
This is why I also say Mamoru definitely wasn’t jealous of Demande that time he kidnapped Usagi, why would he be worried about Usagi possibly preferring Demande to him when the guy literally almost raped her and took her by force? How does jealousy as an emotion enter the equation here at all? At most it’s protectiveness and possessiveness, not jealousy.
Unless you’re saying that Usagi isn’t even so much crazy jealous as she is simply afraid any person who takes an interest in him is simply attempting to kidnap and brainwash him? If so, then yeah I would say that definitely makes sense why that would cause her to be more paranoid around other potential love interests but that’s not
jealousy.
Because many Westerners have your bizarre hatred of traditional and even mythic romances. In fact even in the West most fans do like Mamoru and Chibiusa and the Miracle Romance is loved. Mamoru and Usagi are a very popular couple in Western Sailor Moon fandom and in Japan Mamoru and Chibiusa and the Miracle Romance are more universally loved. The only reason as to why it is hated in the West is usually because Western fans in general have this hatred for anything seen as sappy or traditional and have this crock of [BLEEP] idea about agency that because 2 people are bound by each other in love especially a love that crosses time they have no "agency"
If that’s the case, that the “destined lovers” trope is only found as cringe in the West then how do you explain that page from that other manga I showed you? Why is that mangaka making fun of her own destined lovers ship in-universe and the characters that
she wrote (Who are all Japanese mind you) are reacting to it like it’s cringe?
Bash on Demande/Saphir all you want but at least their relationship is never made fun of or treated as a joke by Ikuhara, Saphir may be a cuck but at least his feelings are taken seriously and no one views it as cringe, meanwhile destined lovers ships like that couple and UsaMamo are constantly being made fun of and treated as cringe by their
own writers! Embarrassing.
So that just proves that even the Japanese today realize that that’s a silly trope and a ship based in that foundation can’t be taken seriously, it is rightfully seen as cringe and made fun of by it’s own f*cking writers/creator who supposedly ships it.
No wonder Rumiko tried to deconstruct that trope through InuKag, I’m so glad she decided to make Kagome and Kikyo two completely separate people who Inuyasha is torn between and doesn’t view as the same because it at least explicitly confirms Inuyasha fell for Kagome
for herself and nothing else, if she didn’t InuKag would’ve been cringe as a ship too.
which again among many other things probably explains the high rate of divorces in the West
Don’t kid yourself, the only reason why Asian couples don’t have as high of a divorce rate is for appearances sake and all in the name of family duty and honor because divorce is seen as shameful in those cultures. A lot of them aren’t really happy together or even in love and cheat on each other all the time, hell the whole reason why Japan is currently undergoing a population decline and Otaku Waifu culture is taking over is because the women are now refusing to marry the men unless they’re treated better and they’re demanding real love and agency that Western women have expected in their relationships for years now, that intimidates the still very traditional and patriarchal Japanese men though so they simply turn to 2D women to cope rather than have to deal with actually putting in effort in their relationships beyond just societal duty.
In fact I wouldn’t be surprised if that’s the reason the whole destined lovers/red string of fate shipping trope is as big in Asia as it is, their whole culture is based around Confucian duty and obligation rather than individualized free will so of course their idea of peak romance would be tropes ultimately rooted in forced duty rather than agency.
No Mamoru showed feelings of desire for Usagi even during the Makai Tree arc and their relationship was building up. Hell had the ending not happened and the Moonlight Knight not come back to his subconscious the 2 would have probably got together. They became about as close as Usagi and Mamoru did in the manga before their memories came back IE having attraction to each other but not becoming an official couple.
No they weren’t, in the manga he was already kissing Usagi’s
handkerchief out of longing whereas in the 90’s anime he was just getting to that stage where he’d willingly babysit together with Usagi again,
maybe.
and Usagi does seem a little goofy in how she thinks they are destined lovers.
Not just goofy, any sane person would think she’s full on loony and psychotic, which is exactly how Mamoru treats her as whenever she tries to jumpstart his memory.
Plus again like I mentioned before PDA isn't common in Japan.
So why is Usagi always wanting and willing to do PDA with Mamoru but he doesn’t want to do it back to her?
Demande may not reciprocate Saphir’s feelings romantically but it doesn’t seem to me UsaMamo’s romantic feelings towards each other in the 90’s anime are that much more equal either.
Also if it was just because Japanese culture, why do they have way more PDA in the manga?
Also how is listing qualities such as a person is kind and courageous specific qualities that only that person can have but saying it feels wonderful to be around them and they have so much dreams not.
Because characteristics such as kindness, courage, or hell, even their physical appearance at least
says something about that other person. Whereas vague ass-[BLEEP] like “She has a lot of dreams” or “She feels wonderful to be around” tells us diddly squat!
What does “having alot of dreams” even
mean? It feels wonderful to be around Usagi? Okay, but
how/why? Why does it feel wonderful to be around Usagi?
Do you see what I’m getting at? At least listing off specific traits tells us something about the other person in question, while stuff like this tells us absolutely nothing about them as a person so no, it’s not in fact a double standard, I just want Mamoru to be more specific and descriptive in the traits he likes about Usagi and he can’t even list
one.
with Yumemi Yumeno how their teasing became more friendly and even flirty
Their teasing wasn’t friendly or flirty at all in that episode, if anything it got harsher since that’s the episode where Usagi outright calls Mamoru cold-hearted and Mamoru himself is so curt with Usagi and doesn’t even want to
be there doing the portrait.
Also Usagi and Mamoru even showed attraction to one another and Usagi was afraid that this would among other things cause Rei to be jealous and angry at her. So no Usagi still was jealous and showed attraction to Mamoru even after the Rei and Mamoru dating episode.
Being afraid of Rei getting jealous isn’t Usagi
herself getting jealous, what? That doesn’t even make sense, how does that correlate? Usagi never once expresses jealousy over Mamoru and Rei dating ever again after that first episode when they start going out. In fact not only does she never get jealous again but she actually gets angry on behalf of Rei’s honor, or are you forgetting that the whole reason why both she and Mamoru managed to get roped into Yumemi’s portrait proposition was because Usagi saw them together and thought Mamoru was cheating on Rei and was ready to blast him over that?
Also Rei knew that Mamoru's true feelings was for Usagi because again she knows that Usagi and Mamoru certainly feel as much and admitted as much to each other in the Starlight Tower episode.
You mean cause she saw their feelings as Princess Serenity and Endymion? That only proves my point even further that she only gave up Mamoru cause she felt she had to in the name of destiny, she only knows Serenity and Endymion love each other
not Usagi and Mamoru.
Plus even as Dark Endymion he was oddly protective of Usagi and the Brainwashing wasn't that effective in removing his desires and love towards her like it was in the manga and Crystal. In fact Sailor Moon was able to heal him and Mamoru had to be captured again and have Metalia practically mind rape him to act like a drone to not be in love with her anymore.
He wasn’t protective of her even while under brainwashing because he was
in love with her, but simply because he is fundamentally a good guy and it’s hard to brainwash him completely because his good heart resists.
It had nothing to do with him being in love with Usagi or not, hell even while brainwashed he was kind and attempted to help that Lake Monster find peace and was genuinely happy for her once she did.
Also Mamoru would get frustrated with Usagi and bicker with her and fight but still be as immature as Rei sticking her tongue out at him.
And when did Mamoru ever stick his tongue out at Usagi?
Usagi and Mamoru do act comfortably around each other in the Makai Tree arc and become friendly.
Of course they do but they don’t become
best friends who trust each other with their life the way InuKag do before they get together.
And again Mamoru is uncomfortable when she just glomps on him in public at first but eventually becomes receptive to Usagi's affections for him in the Makai Tree arc and has fun with her.
He has fun with her sometimes I admit but he never likes her glomping onto him again and coincidentally she never tries it again either cause she eventually realizes how creepy she comes off.
and because he fills a whole in his life.
So you admit Mamoru is with Usagi because he needs someone to fill the hole in her heart? I just said that’s also not a good reason for being with someone, couples should only be together because of who they are as
people (either personality wise or physical attraction wise) period. If you’re with your significant other for any other reason then the feelings are fake and forced, you should be with them because you like them for
who they are, not out of a forced destiny or because you want them to rescue you and use them as a crutch. Fix your own life first before getting involved with someone then, because then it’s just trying to put a band-aid on the problem and using the other person.
and yes Mamoru was in love with Usagi at that moment. He and she all ready had love and attraction to one another before hand especially as Sailor Moon and Tuxedo Mask and this came to it's fulfillment at the Starlight Tower.
Attraction yes but not love, they barely even
knew each other as Usagi and Mamoru and were only starting to get to know each other in the Starlight Tower. They were no where near ready to start declaring their everlasting love for the other like they start doing as soon as they awaken as the Prince and Princess.
You do realize that by your own stupid logic you can never give any specific qualities you love about a person because anyone on the planet can have those exact same qualities as well.
You do realize there’s a difference between loving someone for their specific qualities and loving them simply because of the circumstances you’re under right? UsaMamo fall into the latter category cause they would’ve
never gotten together otherwise if they hadn’t been Sailor Moon/Tuxedo Mask or Serenity/Endymion, the Makai Tree arc pretty much proves this. (Since Usagi was still thinking Mamoru was a jerk and outright drooling over Ail and she and Mamoru only fell in love
after they both got their memories back).
I bet that’s why Mamoru can’t even list any specific traits inherent to Usagi herself as the reason why he loves her, I mean it’s not like he’s with her because of her stunning personality or even her looks so the best he can come up with outside of “destiny/she can fill the hole in my heart and give me the family I never had” are vague-ass statements like “she has a lot of dreams” or “it feels wonderful to be around her,” stuff that tells us nothing about Usagi
as a person!
To bring up Fruits Basket again, really how is it any different from this scene here?
Context: The guy is saying that he wishes the one he was destined for who came to him in a prophetic dream could’ve been someone because the girl in question is so hard to love and he doesn’t even like her personally or feels like they’re compatible. Dude is literally admitting here that the girl in the dream could’ve been anyone and he would’ve gotten together with them all the same, how is this not the same thing as Mamoru being with any girl who turned out to be the Princess and Sailor Moon and vice versa for Usagi? It was never because they fell for each other
as people independent of their past lives or secret identities, so yes just like the ship in this series here anyone could’ve easily filled the role of Usagi for Mamoru, just like this guy is saying it could’ve been any girl in that prophecy, hence why Mamoru finds it so difficult to name specific
characteristics he actually likes about Usagi and why the guy in that scene worded it the way he did how he wishes he could’ve dreamt of someone else - why didn’t he just say he wishes he could’ve
loved someone else? Because he like Mamoru is only with his girlfriend because of special circumstances and cause they just happened to be the one in that position, not because of who they actually are as people.
Say what you will about Demande/Saphir, InuKag, or Momoko/Yousuke, dysfunctional or not but at least for all these ships it wasn’t just circumstances that brought them together, for them it
couldn’t be anyone else. For Saphir it had to be Demande because of the kind of person Demande is not just because he happens to be his brother and anyone could’ve filled that role, likewise with Kagome if it was someone else pinned to the Tree that she released and got stuck traveling with like say Sesshomaru, she would’ve never given him the time of day because she’s specifically attracted to the kind of person Inuyasha
is and always has been.
Also Demand dosen't love Saphir as a person. Maybe as a brother yes but not as a lover
Loving him as a brother
is loving him for the kind of person he is even if it’s not romantic.
He dosen't even give Saphir the equal title of Prince even though he is his brother.
This is actually one of the reasons why I doubt Demande and Saphir are actual brothers, because don’t you think if they were Saphir would have the title of Prince too and be considered royalty? Makes me think his whole calling Demande “nii-san” thing is just meant in the close relationship sense rather than Demande
literally being his brother. Or at most he’s an illegitimate half-brother born from a concubine or affair and that’s why he doesn’t get the Prince title but Demande does.
Even Demande never once refers to Saphir as his brother as in “outoto” (which can
only mean “little brother” in the literal sense) and simply refers to him as “Saphir.”
The fact that you see it as "looking like pedophilia" is because you are a woke puritan and your ideas have always been woke despite your protests.
Again I ask, what does “disliking pedophilia” have to do with wokeism? How is the dislike of pedophilia related to politics in any shape or form and isn’t a universal value much like being against murder is?
How the f*ck is it even being a puritan? I’m not clutching my pearls over how much explicit sex consenting adults are having, or what kinks/fetishes they have or even how much skin they show. Thinking a relationship looks pedophilic simply has to do with the difference in mental level and maturity between the couple as well as the actual, physical judgement. It’s not making any value judgements over how much sex they’re having or what kinds of sex, which is what being a puritan is about. Honestly you need to check the definitions of words before you just throw them around like that. Thinking a relationship looks pedophilic has nothing to do with politics or being a puritan.
I’m not the only one who thinks this by the way, most of the SM fandom also thinks UsaMamo in the 90’s anime looks pedophilic, or why else do you think Mamoru still gets debates over his age brought up even till today? Is the SM fandom suddenly all filled to the brim now with “Christian puritans?”
It’s not even making a value judgement on their relationship, it’s an objective fact that UsaMamo looks pedophilic in the 90’s anime because of their heightened age gap and maturity chasm - not even saying now whether this is good or bad, it just is what it is.
Also it was obvious that Wiseman attacked Saphir in the story there is no question of that but Demand still chose to side with him and only gave his life for Sailor Moon not his brother that you think he is boning.
He didn’t “side with him,” he specifically ordered Wiseman to wait and stop but Wiseman didn’t listen and that was the first time he ever disobeyed Demande’s orders directly so Demande was simply too shocked to be able to do anything in time. (Whereas with Sailor Moon he had found out about Wiseman’s true nature and was already fighting him so this time he knew where Wiseman was aiming at right away).
Again what is the issue with a couple acting like parent and child. Hell I love father/son incest relationships in fanfic and honestly that is what Kunzite and Zoisite act like. Hell the French dub even tried to make them uncle and nephew. Again you can have large gaps in maturity in a relationship and still be a good couple. Besides as many have stated there are different levels of maturity I would argue in terms of interpersonal and social skills Usagi is much more mature then Mamoru is. Honestly in many cases where Usagi lacks Mamoru excells and vice versa. That is why they as opposites attract.
That’s only if the more mature partner actually relates to their lover like a lover, which Kunzite does but Mamoru doesn’t with Usagi. For example when has Kunzite ever gotten exasperated or embarrassed by Zoisite the way Mamoru has Usagi? Never, he embraces his affections eagerly and returns them just as much in kind. Whereas it’s like pulling teeth to get Mamoru to behave romantically or affectionate towards Usagi in the 90’s anime.
Also Inuyasha and Kagome's relationship is just as much wide a gap in maturity
It is not because Kagome always loses her composure with Inuyasha and his actions and words emotionally affect her to the point where she loses her temper and they yell and bicker at each other back and forth whereas Mamoru rarely let’s Usagi’s antics bother him and he’s always the one staying calm, cool and collected like the mature adult in the situation, hence the wider maturity gap.
If Kagome was so much more mature than Inuyasha on the level of Mamoru in the 90’s anime, then she wouldn’t even get frustrated or mad at Inuyasha to begin with and would simply humor his antics the way Mamoru does Usagi’s.
and Momoko acts like a crybaby while Yousuke is a more mature boy though less mature then Mamoru
Yes he’s not
as mature as Mamoru, that’s exactly why he and Momoko work,
because the maturity gap isn’t as wide as UsaMamo in the 90’s anime.
Like I said it’s fine if there’s a
little maturity gap like the ones InuKag and Momoko/Yousuke have, but not if it’s a gaping wide chasm that prevents someone from even
engaging with their partner as an equal like the way 90’s anime UsaMamo are.
Hell Sesshomaru certainly dosen't act as mature or even beastial as Inuyasha acts and he is a full dog demon.
That’s simply because Sesshomaru is older than Inuyasha, he’s 19 in demon years to Inuyasha’s 15 so he’s already technically an adult (like 90’s anime Mamoru) compared to Inuyasha still being a teenager. Plus Sesshomaru was raised in high-class aristocracy from birth so that’s why he conducts himself more high-class and civilized than Inuyasha does, you’re comparing apples to oranges.
And Momoko and Yousuke's love is forbidden just like Usagi and Mamoru's love us.
Yes but it’s not
destined, and that’s the key difference and what makes Momoko and Yousuke’s love already 10 times better than UsaMamo.
just like I imagine that Sailor Uranus and Sailor Neptune were lovers in the past Silver Millennium too.
Please don’t, HaruMichi are such a great couple and are already the fan-favorite in the fandom, you’d be ruining them if you made them into another UsaMamo 2.0
What’s so appealing about them as a ship is the fact they weren’t bound together in a past life and only managed to find themselves in this life, simply because of who they are as people here in the present. Their relationship actually indicates a break and change
away from the past rather than a repeat of it since back in the Silver Millenium it was stated that the Outers were all alone guarding the Solar System from outside invaders from afar and they never so much as met each other (which makes it impossible that they were ever together in the past) whereas in this life they managed to overwrite that destiny and find each other so they’ll never be lonely again, it’s a powerful statement that their present lives matter more than their past lives and is what’s really important, they’re like the anti-thesis to the whole “destined lovers” trope and that’s precisely what makes them so great to begin with!
Hell in the 90’s anime Michiru admits that she was so happy that the premonition she got about her partner Uranus who she had to find turned out to be Haruka because she had always been watching and admiring Haruka from afar and was already in love with her, even before she found out she was Sailor Uranus. Now
that’s how you do a “destined partners coming together via a prophecy” properly and convincingly, Michiru would’ve still been in love with Haruka even if they were never Uranus and Neptune. She thought Haruka was simply dazzling and loved and admired how she was as free as the wind to the point where she had been secretly painting portraits of her in longing!
If it was revealed they were a couple in the past too it would simply undermine the whole point and message of their relationship that despite their lives being bound up in duty arguably more than any of the other Senshi their relationship with each other is the one thing they chose for
themselves as civilians, and they desperately
wish they could be free from their duties and fate which prevents them from fully consummating their relationship because they have to focus on “their Mission” at all times.
HaruMichi are a beautiful ship
because they aren’t destined and chose each other in this life for themselves.
Also I find maturity gaps in relationships fun, funny and romantic. Hell many characters I like have the dynamic of the goofy imature partner and the one more mature and collected.
Sure, but it’s not fun or romantic if the more mature partner is so mature he’s barely even reacting to his partner and is just humoring her and being exasperated with her the way Mamoru does with Usagi in the 90’s anime once they finally get together.
Also Moonlight Knight didn't go against the story of the Makai Tree arc of Usagi and Mamoru coming together without their memories as Moonlight Knight is a projection of Mamoru's desire to protect USAGI the girl and again in Sailor Moon
And why did that subconscious desire to protect
Usagi in particular? It’s not because he fell in love with her naturally but simply because she saved him from Beryl and Mamoru was subconsciously grateful to her for that.
Also it was stated in the 90s anime that unions between people of Earth and the Moon were forbidden in fact that is what led to the war as the people of Earth didn't like Endymion falling in love with the Moon Princess. In fact Princess Serenity wasn't even allowed to go to Earth but she did so anyway.
Where was this stated in the 90’s anime specifically? Cause I don’t remember them ever making any mention of Earth-Moon relationships being explicitly
forbidden in the Silver Millennium backstory episode in episode 44. Or do you mean it was mentioned in Another Story?
Kagome and Inuyasha admitted their feelings for one another but never acted like a couple or even acted like they became one.
That’s where you’re wrong because they had plenty of times where they acted as a couple throughout the series, not just at the very end. They frequently cuddled together and held hands throughout the series and Inuyasha even tried kissing her at one point! (Plus when Kagome herself kissed him in the 2nd Movie simply to break the spell on him, Inuyasha gladly kissed her back once he snapped out of it)
Also in episode 48 when Inuyasha is contemplating leaving Kagome for Kikyo, and Miroku, Sango and Shippo all chide him for this Inuyasha’s reaction is “Do you want me to break up with Kagome that much?!” indicating that yes, Inuyasha did in fact consider he and Kagome to be dating.
Also Usagi and Mamoru are compatible.
Not intellectually they’re not, they don’t even share any of the same interests. Remember how in the S movie they were on a date and Usagi was asking Mamoru for advice on Luna but he was too engrossed in his book to even care and he ended up having to comfort Usagi and reassuring her because she rightfully believed he didn’t enjoy spending time with her.
Usagi loves Mamoru's more mature and dedicated demeanor which rubs off of her and Mamoru loves her fun loving kind and goofy demeanor which rubs off of him.
They never say this is what they love about the other and neither of their demeanors rub off on each other, Mamoru never loses his composure and allows himself to become goofy, if anything he matures and gets even
more serious as the series goes on.
And Usagi actively
regresses in maturity during SuperS and only really starts maturing during Stars when Mamoru isn’t even around around anymore.
Also in the 90s anime Usagi and Mamoru stated that they love each other not just because of destiny but because it feels wonderful to be around each other among other things.
Come to think of it,
has Usagi ever said why
she loves Mamoru? I don’t think she even gives her own reasons even once throughout the entirety of the 90’s anime, she most certainly never said it’s because it feels wonderful being around Mamoru, which even Mamoru could say that much even though that’s still a lame-ass reason for loving someone.
Plus not anyone can give you a family. Family is a very special thing.
True, but you should at least be able to list the qualities on
why this person is so special that you choose them to be the one to give you a family, which Mamoru never does.
Also he never acts like a she’s psycho
His reaction to her whenever she starts glomming onto him and telling him about their past life during the Makai Tree arc
isn’t him acting like she’s stark-raving nuts?
certainly dosen't treat her as a daughter.
Him essentially “grounding” her from their dates, telling her to behave herself in front of Saori and Kobayashi and treating her basically the same as Chibi-Usa and not being very affectionate her while acting like he’s babysitting her during their dates
is treating her like a daughter.
Not to mention there’s even this scene in SuperS I forgot to mention:
Remember the cavities episode where Mamoru acts like a lecturing parent and forces both Chibi-Usa and Usagi to the Dentist? Remember at the end of the episode when Usagi leans in to kiss him and Mamoru’s first instinct rather than to kiss her back is to open her mouth and check for cavities? You know the way a Daddy does his daughter? You call that normal boyfriend behavior?
And again I’m not the only one who noticed this either. Several in the fandom have made the remark that they felt Mamoru treats Usagi more like a daughter in the 90’s anime than an actual lover.
but everyone gets exasperated with their lovers at time
Not to the extent Mamoru does. Do you see any of the other couples or ships in the 90’s anime getting exasperated by their love interests the way Mamoru does Usagi?
Besides I would rather someone treat me like a daughter in a romantic relationship then a subordinate like Demand treats Saphir or like how Kagome treats Inuyasha like a non sentient animal.
Why?
Hell Sesshomaru a full dog demon would never tolerate being treated the way Kagome treats Inuyasha.
Because he and Kagome were never compatible in the first place.
Also Ami isn't a Mary Sue in the 90s anime. Also I actually liked in SuperS we got to see her take up hobbies other then studying like writing music for instance.
Taking up other hobbies and interests it’s fine, what I have issue with is the fact that she was already considered an expert in all these things from the start and that’s what makes her a Mary-Sue.
Also Minako is book dumb but not as book dumb as Usagi. Usagi can get good grades when she tries problem is she dosen't. Minako tries but still gets bad grades. Also Minako is more street smart but also she was active as a hero longer then any of the Inners and was the first to awaken. Hell Minako was able to spot Tin Nyanko unknowingly in all of her guises on Sailor Stars.
And yet despite being more book-dumb, Minako
still isn’t as immature or childish as Usagi.
Also the scene with Usagi was not infantilizing. Again Usagi likes to look cute. Plus in Japan more so in the West cuteness is synonymous with sexy. While we tend to prefer in many cases women looking hot and even like vixens Japan tends to prefer more neoteny in women especially. The West tends to go by the Golden Ration of Beauty favoring more of the vixen look for women where as Japan tends to prefer the silver ratio favoring cuteness.
So why don’t any of the other girls act that way? Why don’t we see any of the other couples trying to look infantile to better attract their partner? How come it’s
only Usagi?
And there’s no way that’s considered normal behavior in Japan or else Saori and Kobayashi wouldn’t have reacted the way they did where they thought Usagi was
too infantile for her to even be Mamoru’s girlfriend.
Which again this was no where near as infantlizing as Zoisite acting like a baby needing a bottle with Kunzite.
How exactly does Zoisite behave oh so “infantile” with Kunzite? What’s so infantile about always cuddling up close to your partner and crying on their shoulder when something is bothering you?
Also Kunzite and Zoisite are lovey dovey couples in the actual show. The Radio Drama is just going from that. However if your only evidence for Saphir being a brocon is from the Audio Dramas then you don't have good evidence..
Yes and Saphir is also a brocon in the show, as indicated by his profile description in the R Memorial Book and the two scenes in episode 83 and 85 which even DIC had to censor. (His confession of hating Sailor Moon out of jealousy just like Esmeraude does being changed into him confessing secret feelings for her and that hairbrush scene in episode 85 getting completely cut)
Plus even Petz herself alludes to this in the show that this is the reason for her break-up with Saphir and her nasty grudge against men that followed, in episode 86 once she finds Saphir collapsed on the ground and takes him to her apartment to tend to her wounds, she says rather bitterly when he tries to get up and leave “There you go again… always only caring/thinking about Prince Demande.” (P.S: This line was also censored in the dub and changed into “you’re in absolutely no condition to go to him with those injuries!”)
Even the Memorial Book outright states that “Petz loved Saphir but he could only see Demande.”
So yes, Petz being bitter at Saphir being a brocon in the Drama CD
is a truth based in the show, just like how KunZoi is a PDA couple and presumably, Mamoru
also treating Usagi as more like a pet he babysits rather than a girlfriend.
Haruka being a bigot against drag queens
This one seems more non-canon then the others I have to admit but then again doesn’t Michiru straight up say Haruka dislikes men in Stars? A lot of TERFs or those with TERFY attitudes aren’t just transphobic but straight up man-haters too.
Also Mamoru was not abusive to Usagi in Classic or in R and the R stuff dosen't count as he did them for the nightmares
There was still a better, less abusive way for him to handle it. Instead of trying to get Usagi to hate him he should’ve behaved like how he ended up behaving in episode 77 from the start - as in tell Usagi the truth about the dreams he’s been having and then firmly and sternly refuse to be together with her for her own good.
Instead he chooses to put her down and degrade her all season so as to get her to hate him, which makes him an emotionally abusive douche.
Also Mamoru was not abusive to Usagi in the Classic again their dynamic was no different then Momoko and Yousuke's dynamic or Inuyasha and Kagome's dynamic
Kagome and Momoko never sunk to the ground in tears whenever they bickered with their love interests, even Usagi never got that bad during her bickering with Rei.
Also Rei was after Mamoru because she thought he would be a good match societally as well as finanically
When did it ever state that Rei was after Mamoru for his money?
and honestly the fact that you were in a relationship in a past life is a much better reason to be in a relationship other then physical appearance. Beauty fades but true love can cross lifetimes and in many religions with reincarnation beliefs like my own they do.
No, no it isn’t, because at least someone’s physical appearance is something only they can have and you’re actively making that choice for yourself and being attracted on your own rather than just being forcibly bound to whoever based on their position/role.
Also admiring a person's dreams and ambition is also a much better reason to get together other then just physical attraction alone.
What does “having a lot of dreams” tell us about a person again? It’s most certainly not referring to their ambition because Usagi has to be the least ambitious person in the the entire series as she just wants to laze away her days sleeping, eating and reading manga/playing video games. Hell her dream “career” in the future isn’t even so much as a career as she just wants to be a stay-at home housewife, likely because she doesn’t want to work much. (Not judging her by the way, I’m also as lazy as her and don’t want to work, in fact I think Feminism advocating for women to have the “right” to be wage slaves like men is just about the worst thing to have happened to our gender and we were in a much better position back when we weren’t expected to work at all)
So I ask again, what does “having a lot of dreams”
mean in Usagi’s case? We know it’s not because she’s ambitious, so what is Mamoru trying to say about her? Nothing, because it essentially adds up to meaningless drivel that doesn’t tell us anything about Usagi as a person.
Also Mamoru has shown attraction to Usagi. He has blushed and smiled many times around her when viewing her etc. He is far from asexual. He is no more asexual then manga Haruka is non binary.
The only time he blushed because of her was during the their elevator ride in the Starlight Tower, and smiling alone isn’t indicative of physical attraction.
He certainly never blushed around her as much as he did around that one big-boobed dentist in SuperS, also he rarely initiates any physical affection even when they’re alone.
Hell it can be fun and entertaining the quintessential opposites attract.
Not
that opposite, couples need a good mix of both similarities and differences to truly work out, like how Inuyasha and Kagome are ultimately as similar to one another as they are different.
Also Mamoru does not discipline Usagi and Chibi-Usa in front of Saori and Kobayashi he just tells them to knock off their fighting. I can tell a friend to knock it off when they are out of pocket but I am just calling them out I am not "disciplining" them.
If he wasn’t disciplining them in that moment then explain their embarrassed reaction where they act all ashamed and guilty right after and timidly apologize? Like they
knew they were misbehaving and here comes dad to lay down the law.
Also siblings do not necessarily have the same maturity levels. I know siblings who are the same age and who have vastly different maturity levels. In fact I know of younger siblings who have a huge maturity gap as they are more mature then their older siblings so that is a lie.
This is true, after all Saphir is more mature than Demande and he’s younger than him but the reason why their maturity gap works and UsaMamo’s doesn’t despite Demande being as dumb or even dumber than Usagi is because Saphir isn’t
as mature as Mamoru and he and Demande are still very much on the same emotional wavelength where they get angry and frustrated with each other and their actions emotionally affect the other whereas Usagi barely phases Mamoru.
Also the Breakup arc wasn't dysfunctional they handled it the best way they knew how not like Demand literally abusing Saphir by physicall assaulting him.
Mamoru was still just as abusive to Usagi in the Break-Up arc as Demande was to Saphir just emotionally instead of physically.
And in fact their relationship
can be labeled as physically abusive too from Usagi’s side, because unlike Kagome’s various sits of Inuyasha, Usagi slapping him for forgetting her birthday wasn’t played for laughs and was framed as a serious scene where she was way out of line.
Also Usagi acted like a crybaby in that second episode with Mamoru because again that was her before she matured more and she sometimes did cry when other people corrected her and even cried around Rei if Rei was especially vicious
Never to the point of sinking to the ground like she did with Mamoru there though.
Also the hairbrush scene is not necessarily indicative of a relationship and Demand very much knows how to manipulate people.
He most certainly does not, I mean think about it, if he did then why doesn’t he just try to manipulate Usagi into loving him but instead just takes the brute-force approach? Wouldn’t it be smarter to simply seduce Usagi into loving him? After all you catch more flies with honey than with vinegar after all.
He never tries to manipulate Esmeraude either when she also is crushing on Demande.
And besides if that action really was just to better manipulate Saphir and get him to do his bidding and wasn’t genuine, then why wouldn’t he just cut-out the middle man and hypnotize him into obeying? He doesn’t have to go to all that trouble to manipulate
anyone when he has hypnosis brainwashing powers that can force anyone into doing his will.
Face it, he did it because he wanted to and is attracted to Saphir, either consciously or subconsciously. It may not be as strong as his attraction to NQS, but it’s still there.
It is fanservice but nothing to suggest they are in a relationship.
So you admit that was a flirty gesture?
Also no one’s saying it means they were actually officially together, just that they both had a secret attraction to each other that they never fully acted upon.
Also Mamoru didn't act like a father in that scene he acted like a boyfriend dealing with a raging girlfriend. A dad would have punished Usagi for striking him.
Some dads do if they’re the strict type, other dads are complete push-overs and are constantly indulging and giving into their daughters like that.
Also Usagi and Mamoru's feelings are on the same page they both love each other but their jealousy levels aren't. People can be in a good relationship but have one partner be more jealous then the other.
To the extent where Usagi is
always getting jealous and insecure and Mamoru never does? No, that’s not healthy.
Also why don’t we ever see Mamoru attempting to help Usagi overcome her insecurities and soothing her by reassuring her there’s nothing for her to even be jealous
about? That’s what a really good boyfriend would do, but no he just lets her go on and make a fool of herself and doesn’t ever give her a reason to think otherwise.
Also Mamoru is hot I would even argue a 10 and since he frequently features in yaoi art your opinion means nothing.
Him being featured in a lot of yaoi isn’t a good indication of his hotness. That’s just shipping, and shipping is based on chemistry not how hot two people look together (or at least it
should ideally
, be based solely on that).
I ship Mamoru/Fiore not because they’re “hot” together but because they have a good dynamic and meaningful relationship.