Do you agree with this Reddit post and comments about how Naoko being hated on?

[MamoRei4Life]

https://www.reddit.com/r/sailormoon/s/cOLyxvOHeV

 

[Maraviollantes]

Yes. We are evil like that.

 

[Memelord_Yoshi]

@Talentless Fool @Lady Pen @Hadibou @Neo King Rose

Oh. Look. The OP.

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm..........sounds familiar. Sounds very familiar.

 

[Neo King Rose]

I don't take reddit serious
they could say Naoko put cotton candy on her nose to remind herself what chibiusa's hair color is and
fools will think it's true lol

 

[Memelord_Yoshi]

I don't take reddit serious
they could say Naoko put cotton candy on her nose to remind herself what chibiusa's hair color is and
fools will think it's true lol

It's interesting that the Dislike button subtracts the total 'Likes' on Reddit unlike Youtube's. Very interesting indeed.

 

[Neo King Rose]

It's interesting that the Dislike button subtracts the total 'Likes' on Reddit unlike Youtube's. Very interesting indeed.

actually it is interesting

 

[Rika-Chicchi]

Again, Mara is on the headlines.

 

[Talentless Fool]

@Talentless Fool @Lady Pen @Hadibou @Neo King Rose

Oh. Look. The OP.

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm..........sounds familiar. Sounds very familiar.

Oh Lordy Lord!

'Not really. The MANGA has the tendency to stick up to surface-level traits and repetitive storylines limited the potential for deep, meaningful growth seen in the ANIME. It often added or altered relationships and resolutions in ways that didn't always align with the characters' established personalities or the story's core theme.

#FIXED!

Sometimes I have to wonder if Naoko stans have recently read the manga...
What character development? What deep storyline??? The manga's different arcs have a core theme???
Repetitiveness??? Have you READ the manga? It couldn't be more mechanically structured in it's writing - the 1st half of Black Moon and Infinity are basically filler and the 1st half of Dreams is MEANINGLESS because the character's 'development' doesn't even end up mattering because they are all reset by the next pages.

The 90s anime has ugly and bad art/animation and bad storylines - it's only loved because of nostalgia.
Sure, honey that's why Crystal despite it's very low animation and art is applauded for it's amazing characters and storyline... oh wait.


Reddit vs SailorMoonForum's toxic members:

PS: Who has a hate club over there already? Me or LadyPen?

 

[Rika-Chicchi]

^ Beware that your post could also appear on Reddit like Mara's.

 

[Memelord_Yoshi]

^ Beware that your post could also appear on Reddit like Mara's.

Just the perfect place to post Joan Crawford memes.

 

[Memelord_Yoshi]

Reddit vs SailorMoonForum's toxic members:

If you click on the OP's username you'll see all of his posts from the start(at the very bottom). And the first posts/thread was deleted due to the number of dislikes the OP's replies with the narrative he was trying to sell here as well.

https://www.reddit.com/r/sailormoon/comments/1dougmz

 

[Rika-Chicchi]

At least in regard to the claim that social media killed the forum, forums are still relevant, even in the social media itself. lol

 

[kasumigenx]

I am less active there than here...though.

 

[Lady Pen]

Reddit.... That site where nobody can have a personality, force to give their opinions in the most sterile way (just in case someone takes offence). .... please...................

@Talentless Fool @Lady Pen @Hadibou @Neo King Rose

Oh. Look. The OP.

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm..........sounds familiar. Sounds very familiar.

Reddit urgently needs WDYWSMC memes. As urgent as suppressing appetite.

Everyone there is cutie-cutie. According to them Naoko is a great person because.................................................................................................................because........................................................................................................................she has a beautiful art.....

I don't take reddit serious
they could say Naoko put cotton candy on her nose to remind herself what chibiusa's hair color is and
fools will think it's true lol

They think she's still recovering from the stress she suffered 30 years ago, as if the rest of mangakas had the best employment conditions ever. They need to keep victimising Naoko to continue breathing. Don't tell them the truth, their life-structures will collapse forever.

Sometimes I have to wonder if Naoko stans have recently read the manga...
What character development? What deep storyline??? The manga's different arcs have a core theme???
Repetitiveness??? Have you READ the manga? It couldn't be more mechanically structured in it's writing - the 1st half of Black Moon and Infinity are basically filler and the 1st half of Dreams is MEANINGLESS because the character's 'development' doesn't even end up mattering because they are all reset by the next pages.

The 90s anime has ugly and bad art/animation and bad storylines - it's only loved because of nostalgia.
Sure, honey that's why Crystal despite it's very low animation and art is applauded for it's amazing characters and storyline... oh wait.

They love the concept of SM, but because they’ve never had a mature or adult version of it to proudly show they're fans of Sailor Moon, they prefer to fill in the many gaps in the manga’s story by using their imagination. Not only that, they convince others to read the manga or watch Crystal, selling them the story they’ve constructed in their heads. But when outsiders find that the manga/Crystal is terrible, the lives and egos of Naoko’s stans feel wounded, and they cope with that emotional pain by creating more fantasies and self-deception. They are marvellous creatures.

Reddit vs SailorMoonForum's toxic members:

PS: Who has a hate club over there already? Me or LadyPen?

A hate club?? That would be wonderful. You-know-who would command it.

Reddit members VS Lady Pen:

Well... Sorry Talentless but you don't have the iconic YES LADY PEN YOU'RE WRONG... JUST LIKE ALWAYS!!!!!!!!!! expression.

Just the perfect place to post Joan Crawford memes.

It would wonderfully spice reddit up.

At least in regard to the claim that social media killed the forum, forums are still relevant, even in the social media itself. lol

Isn't Reddit a sort of social media based strongly on forum mechanisms??

 

[YuYu Yuichiro]

Again, Mara is on the headlines.

Should I put him here now?
Who are the bigger figures in the fandom? | Sailor Moon x Suburban Senshi Forums (sailormoonforum.com)

 

[Rika-Chicchi]

They think she's still recovering from the stress she suffered 30 years ago, as if the rest of mangakas had the best employment conditions ever. They need to keep victimising Naoko to continue breathing. Don't tell them the truth, their life-structures will collapse forever.

Sounds like an info cocoon. lol

They love the concept of SM, but because they’ve never had a mature or adult version of it to proudly show they're fans of Sailor Moon, they prefer to fill in the many gaps in the manga’s story by using their imagination. Not only that, they convince others to read the manga or watch Crystal, selling them the story they’ve constructed in their heads. But when outsiders find that the manga/Crystal is terrible, the lives and egos of Naoko’s stans feel wounded, and they cope with that emotional pain by creating more fantasies and self-deception. They are marvellous creatures.

Sounds like a good case of psychological study. lol

At least in regard to the claim that social media killed the forum, forums are still relevant, even in the social media itself. lol

Isn't Reddit a sort of social media based strongly on forum mechanisms??

Like a social media w/ forum genes? Sounds interesting.

[EDIT]

Again, Mara is on the headlines.

Should I put him here now?
Who are the bigger figures in the fandom? | Sailor Moon x Suburban Senshi Forums (sailormoonforum.com)

Of course!

 

[kasumigenx]

The issue in Reddit is possible downvote mobbing.

 

[Rika-Chicchi]

The issue in Reddit is possible downvote mobbing.

I think both indiscriminate liking & disliking can make them meaningless in time. lol

 

[kasumigenx]

I think both indiscriminate liking & disliking can make them meaningless in time. lol

They worship Sailor Moon Crystal that is why it is not engaging and I got zeroed when I pointed out that the timing of Crystal is wrong because it alienates its target audience when Nakayoshi is serializing Sailor Moon.

 

[PreguntasDesconocidas]

I disagree that this forum is terrible. There can be some tension, but it never goes too far. We're also allowed to express various opinions that are tolerated. By contrast, I once wrote on Reddit that I didn't care for UsaMamo in the 90s anime and got downvoted a tonne.