What Mangaka do you want to make a sequel or spin off of Sailor Moon

  • This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn more.

kasumigenx

Systema Solare
Feb 8, 2021
5,404
2,840
1,665
36
www.deviantart.com
#1
What Mangaka do you want to make a sequel or spin-off of Sailor Moon?

These are the mangaka I wanted to create a spin off.

CLAMP
CLAMP are hinted not like Mamoru just like Ikuhara, but I still like them to do a spin-off but I want it to focus on Haruka and Michiru.

Chiho Saito
She has the same tastes, style, and ideas as Naoko Takeuchi and her art is lovely, she can redo or make a sequel to Sailor Moon, but I like a Reinako story or a MamoUsa story from her.

Ken Akamatsu
I wonder what are his ideas about Sailor Moon since he started being part of the anime/manga community because of Sailor Moon.
 
Last edited:
Jul 6, 2012
883
2,645
1,665
#2
What Mangaka do you want to make a sequel or spin-off of Sailor Moon?

CLAMP
CLAMP are hinted not like Mamoru just like Ikuhara, but I still like them to do a spin-off but I want it to focus on Haruka and Michiru.

Chiho Saito
She has the same tastes, style, and ideas as Naoko Takeuchi and her art is lovely, she can redo or make a sequel to Sailor Moon, but I like a Reinako story or a MamoUsa story from her.

Ken Akamatsu
I wonder what are his ideas about Sailor Moon since he started being part of the anime/manga community because of Sailor Moon.
Honestly I mostly care about the art, so I’d choose Clamp from these 3. Their art is still gorgeous and it would fit nicely the SM universe.

I wish we could have something as beautiful as Lost Canvas was to the OG Saint Seiya manga.
 
Likes: kasumigenx
Apr 30, 2021
708
1,095
1,665
#3
I mean, I'd rather have Takeuchi writing her own sequel, but playing pretend, I'd go for a completely different style, or it would look like a cheap knock off to me.
 
Likes: kasumigenx

Clow

Gurges Ater
Jul 29, 2012
9,607
8,022
1,665
#4
Being a fan of CLAMP, I’d say CLAMP.

But I am not sure what kind of story Nanase Ohkawa would be able to come up with…

Naoko Takeuchi explored every facet of Usagi as a character: we’ve seen Usagi in the past as a fragile princess, in the present as an ordinary student and senshi, in the future as a Queen (and mother), and there is even an ambiguous form of Usagi (Sailor Cosmos), which I’d like to remain ambiguous.
 
Apr 30, 2021
708
1,095
1,665
#8
Being a fan of CLAMP, I’d say CLAMP.

But I am not sure what kind of story Nanase Ohkawa would be able to come up with…

Naoko Takeuchi explored every facet of Usagi as a character: we’ve seen Usagi in the past as a fragile princess, in the present as an ordinary student and senshi, in the future as a Queen (and mother), and there is even an ambiguous form of Usagi (Sailor Cosmos), which I’d like to remain ambiguous.
Omg, if we are letting Ohkawa handle a SM sequel, it probably would end up to be a gory/cute take on "how Sailor Chaos killed everyone".
(And I'd be totally into it, tbf)
 
Feb 20, 2023
317
957
665
#11
Naoko Takeuchi explored every facet of Usagi as a character: we’ve seen Usagi in the past as a fragile princess, in the present as an ordinary student and senshi, in the future as a Queen (and mother), and there is even an ambiguous form of Usagi (Sailor Cosmos), which I’d like to remain ambiguous.
This is why I wouldn't personally want a sequel, everything feels so tied up and the things that were left ambiguous are fascinating precisely because they were left ambiguous, so a sequel exploring those would sort of spoil them.

However, if we must make something new up, then I'd say go for the obvious: a spin-off about the further adventures of Sailor Chibi Moon and the Sailor Quartet.

As for the artist, I'd like for it to be a lesser known or novice mangaka chosen by Takeuchi to carry the torch, I think that'd be neat and it would allow us to get into the story without any preconceived expectations.
 

kasumigenx

Systema Solare
Feb 8, 2021
5,404
2,840
1,665
36
www.deviantart.com
#12
Omg, if we are letting Ohkawa handle a SM sequel, it probably would end up to be a gory/cute take on "how Sailor Chaos killed everyone".
(And I'd be totally into it, tbf)
Sailor Cosmos, not Chaos.
A Chibiusa vs Cosmos sequel makes sense.

Wait, I thought she also retired few years ago?
Loveless is still not finished

This is why I wouldn't personally want a sequel, everything feels so tied up and the things that were left ambiguous are fascinating precisely because they were left ambiguous, so a sequel exploring those would sort of spoil them.

However, if we must make something new up, then I'd say go for the obvious: a spin-off about the further adventures of Sailor Chibi Moon and the Sailor Quartet.

As for the artist, I'd like for it to be a lesser known or novice mangaka chosen by Takeuchi to carry the torch, I think that'd be neat and it would allow us to get into the story without any preconceived expectations.
I think a Sailor Moon spin-off anthology could be made with other mangaka doing tributes to Naoko.
 

Slowpokeking

Aurorae Lunares
Apr 1, 2020
1,583
1,242
1,665
42
#13
I think the top priority

1. Serious, real, conflict. That's what Sailor Moon was good at and most of the other fight shojo anime failed at.

2. Hopeful theme, treat everyone like humans, just like Season 1-2's overall theme.


CLAMP: No, their magic knight couldn't even make a good villain.
 

Clow

Gurges Ater
Jul 29, 2012
9,607
8,022
1,665
#15
This is why I wouldn't personally want a sequel, everything feels so tied up and the things that were left ambiguous are fascinating precisely because they were left ambiguous, so a sequel exploring those would sort of spoil them.
I completely agree. The more you reveal, the more it becomes less interesting.

A Chibiusa vs Cosmos sequel makes sense.
No, I prefer:

Sailor Cosmos and Chaos fall in love.
 

Rika-Chicchi

Staff member
Site Admin
May 7, 2009
46,463
9,574
1,665
#16
Naoko Takeuchi explored every facet of Usagi as a character: we’ve seen Usagi in the past as a fragile princess, in the present as an ordinary student and senshi, in the future as a Queen (and mother), and there is even an ambiguous form of Usagi (Sailor Cosmos), which I’d like to remain ambiguous.
She as a villainess :twistedevil: (while that's already been explored by PGSM, it's not a manga).
 

Clow

Gurges Ater
Jul 29, 2012
9,607
8,022
1,665
#17
The kind of story I’d like, assuming that it comes from Nanase Ohkawa:

Usagi is forced to destroy Sailor Cosmos. What Usagi doesn’t know is that Sailor Moon and Sailor Cosmos are the same being and that Cosmos hid a secret from her: she loves Chaos … and Chaos is revealed as a human and the ultimate form of Endymion.

:kero:
 
Feb 20, 2023
317
957
665
#18
The kind of story I’d like, assuming that it comes from Nanase Ohkawa:

Usagi is forced to destroy Sailor Cosmos. What Usagi doesn’t know is that Sailor Moon and Sailor Cosmos are the same being and that Cosmos hid a secret from her: she loves Chaos … and Chaos is revealed as a human and the ultimate form of Endymion.
Sounds interesting and would explain why Endymion is so prone to being brainwashed by evil, evil is his true ultimate form.

She as a villainess :twistedevil: (while that's already been explored by PGSM, it's not a manga).
That'd be interesting, I love Princess Sailor Moon being the real big bad and her vague connection to Metalia, but I think this would need a bit of a retcon. I thought the reason it worked so well in the live action was because there was a clear contrast between Usagi and Serenity, and also because it was Serenity who destroyed the planet all along (while Metalia was, like, some Silver Crystal phantom thing, the manifestation of her destructive desires, or something). In the manga Usagi is just like Serenity and they have always been good and a protector, so having her be evil would be a bit out left field. Nothing a good ol' retcon wouldn't solve, though.
 
Last edited:

Rika-Chicchi

Staff member
Site Admin
May 7, 2009
46,463
9,574
1,665
#20
Cosmos could become an antagonist & Chaos a protagonist by depicting the former as the embodiment of all-encompassing order by which every entity in the universe must abide, while the latter as the one of individual freedom for them. Hence the two are always in conflict by their very nature, & also like in the original manga, they neither should nor could win over the other, because the existence of the universe always depends on a mutual balance between them.