Worst SM Fanfic you've ever read.

  • This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn more.
A

Anonymous

In general, a lot of MSTs can be found by simply Googling the name "Megane 6.7". There is a fanfic writer named Sailor Mac who did one of a hentai fic called Evening at Lita's, but if you can't find it, you'll have to use the link I provided upthread that goes to an archived copy of A Sailor Moon Romance to find it.
Thanks for the free plug! You can also find Zoogz and my most recent Sailor Moon MSTings at http://www.nabiki.com/mst/recent C&C is always welcome. ;)

Sincerely,

Megane 6.7
 
the fic called Wildflowers

it's a horriable story and disgusting... i red it awhile back and forgot about it.. but on a site someone brought it up.. here is why i hate is so much.. i got this from the site..

In the story, Zoisite was married to Naru (princess of the Earth) through an arranged marriage during the Silver Millenium. He abused her physically, constantly beating and raping her, as well as verbally. She gave birth to Endymion, but after Zoisite informed the King and Queen that Naru was abusing the boy, they took him away from her. That is just the beginning.

there is no way zoisite would do such a thing... :evil:
 

Lunar Archivist

Staff member
Site Admin
Aug 31, 2003
679
2
0
Beaconsfield, Canada
Not so much a bad fanfic as something of an acid trip: the Sailor Soldiers held a secret vote to kill off Usagi because she was a lousy Moon Princess and Jadeite helps her reincarnate as a youma out for her former friends' blood. I read this thing over ten years ago and remember it mainly because it was so utterly bizarre and surrealistic (not to mention ridiculously long), especially the part when alternate universe Usagis started showing up to battle their evil counterpart, including one who was a fearless samurai. :?
 
Sep 1, 2011
9,528
358
165
29
Scala Ad Caelum
Lunar Archivist said:
Not so much a bad fanfic as something of an acid trip: the Sailor Soldiers held a secret vote to kill off Usagi because she was a lousy Moon Princess and Jadeite helps her reincarnate as a youma out for her former friends' blood. I read this thing over ten years ago and remember it mainly because it was so utterly bizarre and surrealistic (not to mention ridiculously long), especially the part when alternate universe Usagis started showing up to battle their evil counterpart, including one who was a fearless samurai. :?
Well, I don't have a reaction image for that, so I'm gonna have to make one.
 
Apr 26, 2011
8,653
5
0
31
"Dai Shocker's Hell Festival."
Lunar Archivist said:
Not so much a bad fanfic as something of an acid trip: the Sailor Soldiers held a secret vote to kill off Usagi because she was a lousy Moon Princess and Jadeite helps her reincarnate as a youma out for her former friends' blood. I read this thing over ten years ago and remember it mainly because it was so utterly bizarre and surrealistic (not to mention ridiculously long), especially the part when alternate universe Usagis started showing up to battle their evil counterpart, including one who was a fearless samurai. :?
I think I read that one. One of those "bad attempts at dark fic" that I mentioned.
 

HarukaMichiru

Luna Crescens
May 5, 2007
126
0
0
58
Florida
Any Sailor Moon/Dragon Ball Universe crossovers

Any Sailor Moon/Ranma crossovers

The fic where an adult Setsuns and a child Hotaru fell in love with eachother and slept in bed together(it was just as bad as a fic where Scooby-Doo and Velma had sex with eachother)

Any fic where Sailor Senshi/Tuxedo Mask/the cats/random good character all team up to betray Sailor Moon :dead:

Fics that make the character so OOC that it makes one want to literally jam a red-hot metal poker up their nose

Any fic that stereotypes Haruka as an alcoholic/cheating scumbag or getting drunk(I guess authors got sick of stereotyping Neflite).

Any dub-bashing fics
 

Lunar Archivist

Staff member
Site Admin
Aug 31, 2003
679
2
0
Beaconsfield, Canada
Roman55 said:
I think I read that one. One of those "bad attempts at dark fic" that I mentioned.
A very long time ago, I started my own fanfic series that was going to incorporate pretty much every cliche and terrible concept ever into it (Sailor Earth, Sailor Sun, self-insertion, dark ficm etc.). Oddly enough, even though I never came close to finishing it, I still regard it with a certain amount of fondness as what did get done was one of the better things I've ever written because the characters took over the story and dictated the plot. Chibi Moon, Saturn, and Pluto - the first of whom I absolutely hate and the latter two being ones who don't do much for me - actually ended up taking center stage and became central to the plot.
 

FlorLola

Lapis Lunaris
Feb 15, 2012
9
0
0
39
HarukaMichiru said:
Any Sailor Moon/Dragon Ball Universe crossovers

Any Sailor Moon/Ranma crossovers

The fic where an adult Setsuns and a child Hotaru fell in love with eachother and slept in bed together(it was just as bad as a fic where Scooby-Doo and Velma had sex with eachother)

Any fic where Sailor Senshi/Tuxedo Mask/the cats/random good character all team up to betray Sailor Moon :dead:

Fics that make the character so OOC that it makes one want to literally jam a red-hot metal poker up their nose

Any fic that stereotypes Haruka as an alcoholic/cheating scumbag or getting drunk(I guess authors got sick of stereotyping Neflite).

Any dub-bashing fics
i completely agree with this! (though i never ever read any crossovers, so... won't comment on that bit)

also, any fic where haruka is a man, has the magical ability to become one or is a transgender. no offence to the lgtb community (at all!), but i just hate it when they completely change the characters like that. maybe i have a really strong opinion about her, but i see her as a way too proud gay woman for ever even consider changing genders...

any hotaru-chibiusa fic where they are both kids. seriously....

fics where mamoru is not only a jackass but also a rapist. come on! you can hate the guy all you want, but he throws roses, ok? he's harmless!!! dorky? yeah. cheesy? oh yeah. a rapist?? unless we're talking about some role-playing fantasy thing between him and usagi (and still, very hard to picture it...), highly doubtful...

any fic where any of the senshi is the mean, heartless b*tch or a compulsive cheater. way too ooc for my liking...

fics that are all dialogues and nothing else. or that have author's notes in the middle of it... that just annoys me to no ends...


i'm around fanfiction.net a lot, so i've came across all kinds of lousy fics... and i do mean a lot. but i think all the awards go to an usagi-mamoru fic i read a while ago. the story in itself, though it's an already old plot, is well written (well enough to make me keep going, at least) and the whole "brother and sister that are actually not related but they think they are" thing adds more than one twist to the story. but, and here comes the big no-no, usagi is pretty much a slutt that upon mamoru's insistence ends up marrying a guy who is a twisted psycho who enjoys hurting her, abusing her in all and any possible way, and rapes her. and the guy is none other than seiya.
i know it doesn't sound that bad, but trust me, it was. every single character seemed way too out of character. and it's kinda hard for me to picture a slutty usagi, a psycho seiya and a coward mamoru... like i said, the story in itself was not a complete nightmare, i just can't associate such plot/character behaviour to them...


sorry for the long post. venting a little here... :blush:
 
FlorLola said:
HarukaMichiru said:
Any Sailor Moon/Dragon Ball Universe crossovers

Any Sailor Moon/Ranma crossovers

The fic where an adult Setsuns and a child Hotaru fell in love with eachother and slept in bed together(it was just as bad as a fic where Scooby-Doo and Velma had sex with eachother)

Any fic where Sailor Senshi/Tuxedo Mask/the cats/random good character all team up to betray Sailor Moon :dead:

Fics that make the character so OOC that it makes one want to literally jam a red-hot metal poker up their nose

Any fic that stereotypes Haruka as an alcoholic/cheating scumbag or getting drunk(I guess authors got sick of stereotyping Neflite).

Any dub-bashing fics
i completely agree with this! (though i never ever read any crossovers, so... won't comment on that bit)

also, any fic where haruka is a man, has the magical ability to become one or is a transgender. no offence to the lgtb community (at all!), but i just hate it when they completely change the characters like that. maybe i have a really strong opinion about her, but i see her as a way too proud gay woman for ever even consider changing genders...

any hotaru-chibiusa fic where they are both kids. seriously....

fics where mamoru is not only a jackass but also a rapist. come on! you can hate the guy all you want, but he throws roses, ok? he's harmless!!! dorky? yeah. cheesy? oh yeah. a rapist?? unless we're talking about some role-playing fantasy thing between him and usagi (and still, very hard to picture it...), highly doubtful...

any fic where any of the senshi is the mean, heartless b*tch or a compulsive cheater. way too ooc for my liking...

fics that are all dialogues and nothing else. or that have author's notes in the middle of it... that just annoys me to no ends...


i'm around fanfiction.net a lot, so i've came across all kinds of lousy fics... and i do mean a lot. but i think all the awards go to an usagi-mamoru fic i read a while ago. the story in itself, though it's an already old plot, is well written (well enough to make me keep going, at least) and the whole "brother and sister that are actually not related but they think they are" thing adds more than one twist to the story. but, and here comes the big no-no, usagi is pretty much a slutt that upon mamoru's insistence ends up marrying a guy who is a twisted psycho who enjoys hurting her, abusing her in all and any possible way, and rapes her. and the guy is none other than seiya.
i know it doesn't sound that bad, but trust me, it was. every single character seemed way too out of character. and it's kinda hard for me to picture a slutty usagi, a psycho seiya and a coward mamoru... like i said, the story in itself was not a complete nightmare, i just can't associate such plot/character behaviour to them...


sorry for the long post. venting a little here... :blush:
I'm so with you on that Haruka thing... it makes me mad when i see it..

oh and a fic where the person says they know Zoisite is a man... but yet in there fic the make him a woman..

one more thing... welcome to the fourm..
 

FlorLola

Lapis Lunaris
Feb 15, 2012
9
0
0
39
Sailor Swifty said:
I'm so with you on that Haruka thing... it makes me mad when i see it..

oh and a fic where the person says they know Zoisite is a man... but yet in there fic the make him a woman..

one more thing... welcome to the fourm..

i can never picture zoicite as a woman! a gay man, maybe, if we go with the anime. but never a woman....


and, thanks!! :D
 
Jun 1, 2012
861
84
65
33
Hmm... If I write the worst fanfic, I'm gonna say Photo Finish. Usagi used the Disguise Pen saying "Disguise Power! Turn me into the Princess of Ham Land," as she turned into Laura from Hamtaro. would that be the worst fanfic? :?
 
Sep 1, 2011
9,528
358
165
29
Scala Ad Caelum
AlveinHero said:
Hmm... If I write the worst fanfic, I'm gonna say Photo Finish. Usagi used the Disguise Pen saying "Disguise Power! Turn me into the Princess of Ham Land," as she turned into Laura from Hamtaro. would that be the worst fanfic? :?
That... Would just be incredibly weird.
 

EurAsianGirl

Luna Crescens
Aug 14, 2010
174
2
0
31
"Chibi-Usa's 7th Birthday" and the infamous "Artemis's lover" Till this day I still don't know which one is worse... :| I'm sorry, but whoever wrote those two fanfics must either really love defiling Naoko's work, or have the sickest, perviest minds and only got into Sailor Moon cause of the talking furries, lesbians, and lolis.

Looking on the non-hentai side of things, but still being pretty horrific there were two fics I remember coming across. One, was Sailor Moon in Nazi Germany and how the Senshi now have to battle the evil "Hitler" Who's a new power sent by the "Negaverse" and yes, it was "Negaverse in the fic." :| Then there was another one, which changed all the Senshi's nationalities and names and made them Orthodox Hassidic Jews! Sigh...
 
Sep 1, 2011
9,528
358
165
29
Scala Ad Caelum
Lunar Archivist said:
Not so much a bad fanfic as something of an acid trip: the Sailor Soldiers held a secret vote to kill off Usagi because she was a lousy Moon Princess and Jadeite helps her reincarnate as a youma out for her former friends' blood. I read this thing over ten years ago and remember it mainly because it was so utterly bizarre and surrealistic (not to mention ridiculously long), especially the part when alternate universe Usagis started showing up to battle their evil counterpart, including one who was a fearless samurai. :?

 

Rebochan

Lumen Cinererum
Aug 29, 2003
437
6
0
Oh man, this is tough. I used to be involved in the MSTing communities and I read some REAL stinkers, either to work on material for the really old eViL rEbO's Rants series, or material I did when I joined the MSTing community proper.

Hands down, THE worst one I ever worked on was the Misery Senshi Neo-Zero Double Blitzkrieg Debacle.

So, how do I describe it? Well, to say it's a Daria/Beavis and Butthead/Sailor Moon crossover isn't nearly enough to get it across. Nor the fact that the entire work is 1MB in size pre-MSTed.

The monstrousity of a plot begins with Daria taking Ami's place as Sailor Mercury. Then it somehow morphs into several strange plots all at once:

1. A nationalistic terrorist organization in Japan steals a prototype war jet and somehow, with a single plane, defeats the entire air force of all countries, blows up most of Japan, and tries to install military rule.

2. Ami's plane is hijacked by a Muslim terrorist (this story was written pre-2001.) so he can crash it into...

3. ...the great Lawndale/Highland football game, which is also the target of...

4. ...a right-wing American terrorist group's attempt to conquer the town of Lawndale, and during the attack...

5. ...Beavis and Butthead kidnap and try to deflower Quinn Morgendorfer while...

6. ...some guy named the Solar Warrior does stuff that is COMPLETELY unimportant and he really could be written out of the story with no impact!

So, I worked on the MST of this, but the sheer size of it and the time I had meant I let a LOT of stuff slide. Things like

1. The Sailor Starlights being summoned to save Sailor Moon's life, as only Sailor Star Healer can save Sailor Moon, whom they call "their Princess."

2. All of the characters elements being wrong.

3. Sailor Jupiter's family being murdered by Russian terrorists.

...and...and...OH MY GOD...this story has a 40-page appendix explaining EVERY SINGLE JOKE! He write PAGES of information on Japanese culture and society and all of it is WRONG! He tries to describe the Japanese Sailor Moon's plot and all the details even though it's obvious that he's not watched a SINGLE episode outside of the dub!

And Daria! Oh my god, Daria isn't remotely funny!

And then there's the militia and and and ARGH JUST THINKING ABOUT IT IS MAKING MY EARS BLEED MAKE IT STOP PETER GUERIN IS A HAAAAAAAACK